Must have in NYC but fell a little short
I would have rated it 3,5/5 if it would have been possible.
Nice quality, size and it is still possible to fold the stroller.
BUT it is not attached to the seat so it keeps falling off which is annoying when you fold the stroller or take your baby off the stroller. It shouldn't be the case since it is a footmuff specifically designed for this stroller. I also have a Bugaboo and there is a strap that goes around the seat to keep it in place.
Overall it is a good purchase.
ProsGood quality and warm
Large enough that it doesn't restrain my baby too much
Can still fold the stroller when in place
ConsIsn't attached to the seat.